TL;DR: Manual prior authorization costs an Intergy practice in three ways: staff time spent submitting and chasing each request, revenue lost to auth-related denials, and procedures delayed or abandoned while patients wait. Automation pays back by cutting minutes per auth, reducing avoidable denials, and getting services scheduled faster. For a mid-to-large independent practice handling a thousand or more auths a month, the ROI of prior authorization automation for Greenway Intergy usually comes from labor first and denials second, with payback often inside the first year.
The three costs of manual prior authorization
Prior authorization rarely shows up as a line item, which is why practices underestimate it. The real cost is spread across payroll, write-offs, and schedule gaps.
1. Staff time. Every auth needs someone to check requirements, pull clinical notes, fill out a portal form or fax packet, submit, and then check status, sometimes several times. The 2024 CAQH Index found providers and staff spend about 24 minutes requesting an authorization by phone, fax, or email, and 16 minutes through a payer portal. That's just the request, before follow-up calls.
2. Auth-related denials. Claims get denied when an auth was never obtained, expired before the visit, didn't match the billed code, or didn't cover the units delivered. Some of those are recoverable through appeal. Many end up written off.
3. Delayed and abandoned care. When an auth drags on, procedures get rescheduled, imaging slots go unused, and some patients give up or go elsewhere. The AMA's 2024 prior authorization survey found 93% of physicians reported care delays from prior auth, and physicians average 39 prior authorizations per week.
A credible ROI model counts all three. Most practices only count the first, which understates the case.
How to calculate what prior authorization costs your practice
You can build a reliable model from your own Intergy and payroll data in a couple of weeks. Here's the framework.
Labor cost = monthly auth volume × staff minutes per auth (including follow-up) × loaded staff cost per minute
Denial cost = auth-related denials written off per month × average net revenue per denied service
Delay cost = procedures lost or pushed out of the month due to auth delays × average contribution margin per procedure
Total monthly PA cost = labor + denials + delay
Where to find each input:
- Auth volume. Count auth records or PA tasks in Intergy for the last two or three months. Include medication, imaging, procedure, and DME auths.
- Minutes per auth. Run a short time study. Have coordinators log start and stop times for a sample of 50 to 100 auths, including every status check. Follow-up time is often as large as submission time.
- Loaded staff cost. Salary plus benefits, payroll taxes, and overhead, divided by productive hours. Use your payroll data, not a guess.
- Auth-related denials. Pull denials by reason code for missing, invalid, or expired authorizations. Separate what you recovered on appeal from what you wrote off.
- Delay cost. Ask schedulers to track procedures rescheduled due to pending auths for a month, and estimate how many patients didn't return.
A worked ROI example (illustrative numbers)
The figures below are illustrative assumptions, not benchmarks or customer results. Swap in your own data before you show this to anyone.
Assumptions for an example mid-to-large independent practice:
- Auths per month: 1,200
- Staff time per auth today, including follow-up: 30 minutes
- Loaded staff cost: $32/hour
- Auth-related denials written off: 1.5% of auths, at $400 average net revenue each
- Procedures lost to auth delays: 10 per month, at $300 contribution margin each
- Share of auths automation handles as routine: 70%
- Staff time on routine auths after automation: 5 minutes (review only)
- Reduction in auth-related denials and delay losses after automation: half
Current annual cost:
- Labor: 1,200 × 30 min = 600 hours/month × $32 = $19,200/month = $230,400/year
- Denials: 18 × $400 = $7,200/month = $86,400/year
- Delays: 10 × $300 = $3,000/month = $36,000/year
- Total: about $352,800/year
After automation:
- Routine auths (840): 840 × 5 min = 70 hours/month
- Exceptions (360): 360 × 30 min = 180 hours/month
- Labor: 250 hours × $32 = $8,000/month = $96,000/year
- Denials: $43,200/year
- Delays: $18,000/year
- Total: about $157,200/year
Gross annual savings: about $195,600, including roughly 4,200 staff hours a year. Subtract your automation cost to get the net figure.
Two inputs drive almost all of the result: the routine share and the minutes per auth today. Run a conservative case (lower routine share, smaller denial reduction) alongside your expected case. If the conservative case still clears the bar, you have a decision your partners can trust.
Notice that labor makes up about two-thirds of the current cost in this example. That's common, which is why minutes per auth deserves the most careful measurement of any input.
Which costs are easy to miss?
Some of the most expensive parts of prior authorization never appear in a time study. Name them, even if you keep them out of the hard-dollar model.
- Rework. Pended requests that need more documentation can double the work on a single auth.
- Phone hold time. Coordinators who call payers for status or urgent requests can lose a large part of their day on hold.
- Provider time. Peer-to-peer reviews and documentation addenda pull physicians away from patients. The AMA survey found physicians and their staff spend about 13 hours a week on PA work.
- Turnover. PA coordinator roles are repetitive and stressful. Replacing an experienced coordinator means recruiting, training, and months of slower throughput.
- Patient experience. Delays create frustrated calls, complaints, and lost loyalty that rarely gets measured.
The industry-level stakes are large too. CAQH estimated that adopting electronic prior authorization could save the industry $515 million a year and save providers about 14 minutes per authorization.
What should you ask vendors about pricing?
Prior authorization automation is priced several ways, and the model matters as much as the number. Ask every vendor to quote against your actual volume.
- Per-auth pricing. Simple to understand and scales with volume. Check whether you pay for auths that turn out not to be required, and for re-authorizations.
- Per-provider or per-location pricing. Predictable, but make sure it covers all auth types, including imaging, procedures, and infusions, not just medications.
- Platform or per-workflow fee. Common for AI agents that cover multiple workflows. Ask what's included and how pricing changes as you add sites.
- Outsourced service fees. If you're comparing against a service, including EHR-vendor revenue services, ask whether fees are per auth or a percentage of collections.
Also ask about implementation cost, how long the supervised period lasts, and what happens if the routine share turns out lower than promised. Vendors that agree to a measured pilot on your own payers and services are easier to evaluate than ones that only offer case studies.
Payback timing and when the ROI is thin
For a practice with meaningful volume, a realistic timeline looks like this:
- Months 1–2: Setup, payer library build, and a supervised period where staff review every automated submission. Savings are modest.
- Months 3–4: Routine auths for your top payers run with light review. Most of the labor savings appear here.
- Months 5–12: Coverage expands to more payers and auth types, and denial and delay improvements start showing up in revenue data.
Practices with high auth volume often reach hard-dollar payback within the first year. The ROI is thin when:
- Monthly auth volume is low, a few dozen rather than hundreds or thousands.
- Most auths are medications already handled well through e-prescribing ePA.
- Your payer mix is dominated by small plans with idiosyncratic processes.
- Documentation habits are inconsistent enough that exception rates stay high.
If several of these apply, start with process fixes such as triggering auths at the order and building payer documentation checklists, or bundle PA automation with fax triage and eligibility checks so shared setup work goes further.
Where Honey Health fits in the ROI model
The automation in the example above maps to what Honey Health's Prior Authorization agent does. It works on top of Intergy, reading orders and clinical documents, checking payer requirements, submitting through portals and fax, following up on status daily, and recording outcomes so your schedulers and billers see them. Exceptions such as peer-to-peers and medical necessity questions route to your team with context attached.
When you build your model, the agent's work shows up in the two assumptions that matter most: the share of auths handled as routine and the staff minutes left after automation. Pressure-test both in any evaluation. Many practices also add fax triage to the same business case, since a large share of payer correspondence still arrives by fax.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a prior authorization cost a practice?
It depends on staff time, payer mix, and denial rates. The 2024 CAQH Index found staff spend about 24 minutes per manual request by phone, fax, or email and 16 minutes via portal, before follow-up. Add auth-related denials and delayed procedures for the full cost.
How do you calculate the ROI of prior authorization automation?
Estimate current labor, denial, and delay costs from your own data, then estimate the same costs after automation using a realistic routine share. Subtract the post-automation cost and the software cost from the current cost. Keep soft benefits like retention and patient experience in a separate column.
How long does prior authorization automation take to pay back?
Practices with high auth volume often see payback within the first year after a short supervised setup period. Lower-volume practices may take longer, or may get better returns by bundling PA automation with other workflows like fax triage or eligibility checks.
Does automating prior authorization reduce headcount?
Most practices redeploy freed time to appeals, peer-to-peer coordination, patient communication, or growth rather than cutting positions. If reducing headcount is a goal, plan it through attrition and say so plainly in the business case.
Is electronic prior authorization cheaper than manual?
Yes. CAQH estimates that moving to electronic prior authorization saves providers about 14 minutes per request and could save the industry $515 million a year. Automation that handles portals and fax extends similar savings to payers that don't yet support fully electronic transactions.

